What bitter melon and jamun are
Bitter melon is the knobbly green gourd cooked in many Indian kitchens, as karela sabzi, stuffed karela or in sambar. Jamun, also called Indian blackberry or black plum, is a seasonal fruit; its seeds are dried and powdered in traditional preparations. Bottled karela jamun juices usually blend the two, and many add other herbs such as amla, giloy or neem, plus flavourings, sweeteners or preservatives. What is in a bottle varies from brand to brand, which is one reason it is hard to say what any particular juice does.
What research says about bitter melon
The Cochrane review is the most careful summary available. It included four randomised controlled trials with 479 participants, lasting from four weeks to three months. Three of the trials found no significant difference in blood sugar response between bitter melon and placebo, or the medicines glibenclamide and metformin. The authors did not pool the results because the preparations differed so much and the data were of low quality. No trial measured death, complications, quality of life or costs. The authors state that there is insufficient evidence on the effects of bitter melon for type 2 diabetes.
On safety, the review reported no serious adverse effects in any trial. Side effects were mostly moderate, such as diarrhoea and abdominal pain, but the reporting was incomplete. Absence of reported harm in four short trials is not proof of safety for years of daily use.
The NCCIH says in its page on diabetes and dietary supplements that bitter melon is among several herbs studied, along with fenugreek, ginseng and others, that research on them is limited, and that none has been proven effective. It adds that safety information is limited and that some herbal products cause side effects.
Several claims in the older version of this page, including that bitter melon "activates insulin", contains "plant insulin", cleanses the liver, purifies the blood, or boosts immunity, are not supported by this evidence. Laboratory and animal findings about compounds in the plant do not show the same effect in people drinking a bottled juice.
What about jamun?
Jamun is a traditional remedy, and its seeds are widely used in Ayurvedic products for blood sugar. This guide could not verify a Cochrane review, guideline or clinical trial supporting jamun for diabetes, so it makes no claim for it in either direction. The NCCIH statement above covers herbal supplements for diabetes in general: no reliable evidence that any of them controls diabetes. Traditional use, however long, is not the same as evidence from controlled trials, and the real-world product is a blend, so a result for one ingredient does not describe the bottle.
The risks for an older person
Combining with diabetes medicines. The NCCIH says herbal supplements can cause unwanted effects when combined with conventional diabetes medicines and advises people taking diabetes drugs to tell their health care providers about any herbal supplements they use. It also advises against replacing medical treatment with unproven products. Because bitter melon is promoted for lowering blood glucose, a prescriber will want to know about it. The older page warned of a "hypoglycaemia coma"; this guide found no source that measures that risk, but the underlying concern, that two things that lower sugar may together push it too low, is why the prescriber is told.
Low blood sugar is an emergency. The ADA says low blood glucose is a reading below 70 mg/dL, that it is especially common in people with type 1 diabetes or type 2 diabetes taking insulin or similar medicines, and that a severe low, where the person needs someone else to treat it, may involve loss of consciousness and is an emergency. For a self-treatable low, the ADA describes the 15-15 approach: 15 grams of fast-acting carbohydrate, then recheck after 15 minutes. A doctor sets what applies to each person. Confusion, sweating, shakiness or drowsiness in an older person on diabetes medicines after a new product is the kind of picture that calls for a glucose check and medical help.
Stomach upset. Diarrhoea and abdominal pain were the reported effects in the bitter melon trials. For an older person who is already dehydrated, on water tablets or prone to falls, diarrhoea is not trivial.
Kidney disease. The National Kidney Foundation says people with kidney disease can have potassium levels that are too high or too low, and lists vegetable juices among the higher-potassium items for people on kidney diets. It does not discuss karela juice specifically. A person with kidney disease should ask their kidney doctor or dietitian before adding any new juice; see chronic kidney disease home care.
Sugar in the bottle. The WHO defines free sugars as including sugars added to foods and drinks and those naturally present in honey, syrups, fruit juices and fruit juice concentrates. It says free sugars should be limited to less than 10% of daily energy, about 50 grams for someone eating around 2,000 calories a day, and that fruit juice can be consumed but most varieties, including those without added sugar, contain significant amounts of free sugars. The old page's home recipe added honey or jaggery to a fruit-and-karela blend; under the WHO definition those count as free sugars. Labels on bottled juices should be read for sugar and for the list of other herbs.
Other herbs and medicines. Mixed products may contain several herbs. Each adds its own uncertainty, and older adults often take several tablets. The guides on polypharmacy and deprescribing and medicine side effects families should watch explain why a pharmacist or doctor should see the full list, herbal products included.
Claims that do not hold up
- "Take it daily on an empty stomach, 30 ml twice a day." Doses and timings in the older page were not tied to any trial or guideline, and are not repeated here. The Cochrane review notes that preparations varied widely.
- "Treats cancer, dissolves kidney stones, cures asthma." The sources reviewed do not support these claims. Cancer and kidney stones are matters for the person's medical team.
- "Preservatives are harmless" and "no side effects in Ayurvedic studies." These are assurances, not evidence. The Cochrane review reported diarrhoea and abdominal pain.
- "Safe after COVID, boosts immunity." No source supports a juice raising immunity.
Food rather than medicine
Bitter gourd cooked as a vegetable is ordinary food, and a portion at a meal can be part of the fruit and vegetables for which the WHO recommends at least 400 grams a day for people over 10. That is a different matter from a concentrated daily drink taken for its supposed effect on blood sugar. For practical food guidance for older adults with diabetes, see Indian diet for diabetes and diet for diabetic seniors. To understand the condition itself, read what is diabetes mellitus.
When to see a doctor
This guide is general information, not medical advice. It does not replace a doctor, nurse or pharmacist who knows your situation.
Urgent or emergency - The ADA says severe low blood sugar is an emergency. The ADA describes a severe low as one where the person cannot eat or drink, may lose consciousness and needs someone else to treat it. In India call 112.
See a doctor soon - Before a person with diabetes starts any herbal drink or supplement, particularly if they take tablets or insulin. - Blood sugar readings that have become higher or lower than usual after a change in diet or supplements. - Plans to reduce or stop diabetes tablets because a juice "is working". Stopping prescribed treatment has risks that only a doctor can assess. - Persistent vomiting, diarrhoea or weakness after starting any new herbal product. - Kidney disease, liver disease or several other long-term medicines.
Equipment mentioned in this guide
Frequently asked questions
Does karela jamun juice lower blood sugar?
The Cochrane review of bitter melon found insufficient evidence of an effect in type 2 diabetes. The NCCIH says there is no reliable evidence that any herbal supplement can control diabetes.
Can it replace diabetes medicine?
No. The NCCIH advises against replacing medical treatment with unproven products, and any change to medicines is a decision for the prescriber.
Is it safe to take with metformin or insulin?
The NCCIH says herbal supplements can cause unwanted effects when combined with conventional diabetes medicines, and that providers should be told about all herbal products. A doctor or pharmacist can say what applies to a particular person.
What are the side effects of bitter melon?
The trials in the Cochrane review reported mostly moderate effects such as diarrhoea and abdominal pain, with no serious adverse effects, though reporting was incomplete and the trials were short.
Does it cleanse the liver or boost immunity?
None of the sources reviewed support these claims.
Is eating karela as a vegetable different from drinking the juice?
Yes. A cooked vegetable at a meal is ordinary food, while a bottled juice sold for blood sugar is a concentrated product with unknown contents and, in many cases, other herbs and sugars.
Sources and further reading
- Ooi CP, Yassin Z, Hamid TA, Momordica charantia for type 2 diabetes mellitus, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2012)
- National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, Diabetes and Dietary Supplements: What You Need To Know
- American Diabetes Association, Low Blood Glucose (Hypoglycemia)
- World Health Organization, Healthy diet, fact sheet
- National Kidney Foundation, Potassium in Your CKD Diet
Tags: karela jamun juicebitter gourd juicebitter melon diabetesjamunherbal supplements diabetesdiabetes older adultsConditions and devicesBlood glucose meter with stripsHealth monitoring devicesHealthy ageing
This article is for general education and is not medical advice. Ask a doctor or pharmacist about your own situation before changing any exercise, diet or medicine.
