What a tracheostomy is, and what it is not
The trachea, or windpipe, carries air from the throat to the lungs. In a tracheostomy, a surgeon makes a cut in the skin at the front of the neck and a small opening in the windpipe, then places a curved tube through it. The NHS says the tube is held in place with tape around the neck, and that the person then breathes through the tube.
Two terms are often confused with it. A laryngectomy is a different operation in which the voice box is removed, usually for cancer. Some people with a laryngectomy breathe through a permanent opening in the neck, which looks similar but is anatomically different, and emergency care for them differs. The National Tracheostomy Safety Project, a UK charity, publishes separate emergency guidance for tracheostomy and laryngectomy patients for exactly this reason. A cricothyrotomy is a quick emergency airway opening made lower in the throat when no other way to breathe is possible. It is not the same as a planned tracheostomy.
The tubes themselves come in several designs, some with an inflatable cuff, some with a window (fenestration) to allow air past the vocal cords, and some with removable inner liners. Those are covered in a separate guide, Types of Tracheostomy Tubes.
Why doctors suggest one
The NHS says a tracheostomy may be done to help breathing when the throat is blocked, to remove excess fluid and mucus from the lungs, and to deliver oxygen from a ventilator to the lungs. MedlinePlus, from the US National Library of Medicine, lists a wider set of reasons:
- A large object blocking the airway
- Inability to breathe without a machine
- An inherited abnormality of the larynx or trachea
- Inhaling smoke, steam or toxic gases that cause swelling of the airway
- Neck cancer pressing on the airway
- Paralysis of the muscles used for swallowing
- Severe injuries to the neck or mouth
- Surgery around the voice box that makes normal breathing and swallowing impossible
NHLBI adds that stroke, pneumonia and other lung conditions can lead to it when a person needs a ventilator for a long time.
In an older adult, the most common route is a long stay in intensive care. A breathing tube passed through the mouth is comfortable for neither the patient nor the throat over many days. A tracheostomy tube sits below the vocal cords and gives a more direct route for clearing secretions from the lungs, which the NHS lists among its purposes. Clinicians weigh these practical gains against the risks of the operation when a long ventilator course is expected.
When is the right time?
Many families ask whether earlier is better. The evidence says it depends, and the honest answer is that doctors cannot always predict who will need weeks of ventilator support.
In the TracMan trial, published in JAMA in 2013, 909 UK adults on ventilators were assigned to a tracheostomy within four days of intensive care admission or to a later approach where it was done only if still needed. Thirty-day mortality was 30.8 percent in the early group and 31.5 percent in the later group, with no meaningful difference in two-year survival or intensive care stay. Only 44.9 percent of the later group ended up having the operation at all, and the authors concluded that clinicians' ability to predict who would need extended ventilation was limited.
A 2022 JAMA trial, SETPOINT2, compared early tracheostomy with standard care in 382 ventilated adults after severe stroke. It found no significant improvement in survival without severe disability at 6 months. Its authors noted that the wide confidence intervals mean a clinically important benefit or harm could not be ruled out.
Both trials are about intensive care patients in specific settings, not every older person. What they support is cautious: early surgery is not clearly better, and the decision rests on the individual's illness and the outlook for coming off the ventilator.
How the procedure is done
According to the NHS, the surgeon makes a cut in the skin at the front of the neck, creates a small hole in the windpipe and inserts the tube. MedlinePlus describes the operation in similar terms: the surgeon cuts down to the cartilage rings that form the wall of the windpipe, opens it and inserts the tube. It says general anaesthesia is typically used unless the situation is critical, in which case numbing medicine is used.
In intensive care, doctors may use a bedside technique, in which the opening is made through a small incision and stretched to size, often with a camera down the airway for guidance, rather than a full open operation in the theatre. The choice depends on the patient's anatomy, bleeding risk and the hospital's practice. The National Tracheostomy Safety Project offers animations showing how a tracheostomy is inserted, designed with patients and families.
If the patient cannot give consent, the NHS says family members are consulted. This is why relatives often find themselves asked to understand the procedure quickly. Reasonable questions for the team include why a tracheostomy is being suggested, what the alternative is, whether it is expected to be temporary, and who will teach the family tube care.
The first days and weeks
MedlinePlus says that on first waking, a person may feel panicked and unable to breathe or speak, and that this usually eases with time and with medicines to reduce stress. It says most people need one to three days to adjust to breathing through the tube.
Talking is the biggest change. The NHS explains that the tube often has an air-filled cuff, which prevents speech while it is inflated. At first people communicate by writing and gestures. As they recover, air is gradually removed from the cuff and a speaking valve may be fitted to make the voice stronger. MedlinePlus says that with training and practice many people can talk, often with special speaking valves. NHLBI notes that a speech therapist can help with both swallowing and speaking.
On eating, the NHS says many people can eat and drink with a tracheostomy, and if swallowing is unsafe, a thin feeding tube may be passed through the nose into the stomach to give liquid food and fluids. Swallowing problems matter in older adults because food or saliva entering the lungs can cause chest infection. A related guide, Preventing Aspiration Pneumonia in Frail Older Adults, explains that risk.
The NHS says the tube may need changing after 28 days, or earlier if a different tube is needed for breathing or speaking. It describes this as a quick, simple procedure, usually done in hospital.
Risks and complications
All major health bodies describe similar risks. The NHS lists:
- Bleeding in or around the tracheostomy
- Damage to the windpipe or nearby structures
- The tube becoming blocked or moving out of place
- Healing problems after removal, such as infection
- Air building up between the lungs and chest wall, which can cause pain, breathing difficulty or, rarely, a collapsed lung
NHLBI divides risks by timing. Soon after the procedure these include air trapped under the skin, bleeding, infection and collapsed lung. Over time they include scarring of the windpipe, an abnormal connection between the windpipe and food pipe that can let food and saliva reach the lungs, and the tube slipping out of place. MedlinePlus adds anaesthesia risks, injury to nerves, thyroid damage, and a narrowing of the windpipe (stricture) that can occasionally develop.
Blockage deserves special mention. Dried mucus can plug a tube, which is why humidified air, regular cleaning of the inner liner where there is one, and suction by trained people are central to care. The NHLBI page says proper care and handling of the tube and related supplies can lower the risk of complications.
Living with a tracheostomy at home
When a person goes home with a tube, the NHS says that the person or their carer is shown how to clean and care for it before discharge, with support afterwards. MedlinePlus says patients and family members learn tracheostomy care during the hospital stay and that home-care services may be available.
Some practical points described by MedlinePlus: most people can return to their usual life, a loose scarf or similar covering can protect the opening outdoors, and precautions are needed around water, aerosols, powder and food particles, because anything breathed in through the opening goes straight into the windpipe. Bathing and swimming are the obvious cases.
Beyond that, tube cleaning routines, suction pressures and timings, cuff pressure and dressing changes are set by each hospital team, using the specific brand and size of tube the patient has. Numbers quoted on the internet for suction pressure, cuff pressure or tube-change intervals vary with the tube and the patient, and they are best taken only from the discharge instructions. A home nurse, a respiratory therapist and a speech therapist are the usual members of a home team. Where a trained nurse is needed, a guide to home nursing for chronic diseases describes what such a visit covers.
Questions worth putting to the discharge team include what spare tubes and suction equipment the household needs, what happens during a power cut, and who calls the ambulance in an emergency. The National Tracheostomy Safety Project provides free downloadable emergency algorithms and bedhead signs that hospitals and families can use, and the project's patient and family pages include leaflets and videos.
Removing the tube
The NHS says the tube is removed when breathing no longer needs support. That may take days or weeks, or longer in some people. A dressing covers the hole, which usually heals in 7 to 10 days, leaving a scar that fades with time. NHLBI says the opening usually closes on its own, though surgery can close it if necessary. For some people, such as after a laryngectomy, the opening is permanent. MedlinePlus notes that when the tube is permanent, the opening stays open.
Myths and outdated claims
Several claims on older web pages deserve correcting.
- Survival figures. Pages that quote "21 weeks" or "21 months" as the usual survival after a tracheostomy are not describing a real, general statistic. Outcomes depend almost entirely on the illness that led to the tracheostomy. Someone with a blocked airway from injury and someone with advanced lung disease have very different outlooks.
- Tracheostomy is not a failure, a last resort, or a sign that a person is dying. For many people it is a stage on the way to recovery and removal.
- Feeding is not always through a vein. Many people eat normally, and when they cannot, a feeding tube through the nose is the usual option, per the NHS.
- The tube does not mean permanent loss of voice. Speech is blocked while a cuff is inflated, and many people regain speech with a valve or after removal.
When to see a doctor
This guide is general information, not medical advice. It does not replace a doctor, nurse or pharmacist who knows your situation.
Emergency. The NHS says to call emergency services for difficulty breathing in someone with a tracheostomy. In India, the emergency number is 112. The National Tracheostomy Safety Project's emergency pages are written for health staff, and family carers are taught the specific steps by their team at discharge.
Soon. The NHS lists these as reasons to seek urgent advice after going home: problems swallowing, coughing or being sick after eating or drinking, noisy breathing during the day or night including snoring, a raised or uncomfortable scar, pain or discomfort around the tracheostomy especially when swallowing, and a hoarse or weak voice lasting more than a week. Bleeding, a foul-smelling discharge or fever are also matters for the care team, since they may point to infection. Ask your doctor what applies to you.
Equipment mentioned in this guide
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a tracheostomy and a tracheotomy?
The NHS uses both terms for the same procedure. Strictly, tracheotomy means the cut and tracheostomy means the opening that is kept, but in practice they are used interchangeably.
Can a person talk after a tracheostomy?
Often yes, in time. The NHS says that speech is difficult while the cuff is inflated, and that speaking valves can help. MedlinePlus says many people can talk with training and practice.
Is a tracheostomy painful?
The NHS says it is usually done with the person asleep under general anaesthetic. MedlinePlus lists panic, discomfort and difficulty adjusting among early experiences, and says medicines can help.
Is the tube permanent?
Not usually. The NHS says it is removed when breathing no longer needs support, and the opening typically heals within 7 to 10 days. Some people, for example after removal of the voice box, have a permanent opening.
Can someone with a tracheostomy eat normally?
Many can, according to the NHS. If swallowing is unsafe, a thin feeding tube through the nose gives liquid food. A speech and swallowing therapist assesses this.
Does an earlier tracheostomy improve survival in intensive care?
In the TracMan trial of 909 UK adults, it did not. The SETPOINT2 trial in severe stroke also found no significant benefit at 6 months.
Sources and further reading
- NHS, Tracheostomy
- US National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, Tracheostomy
- MedlinePlus, Tracheostomy (US National Library of Medicine)
- Young D et al., Effect of early vs late tracheostomy placement on survival in patients receiving mechanical ventilation: the TracMan randomized trial, JAMA (2013)
- Bosel J et al., Effect of early vs standard approach to tracheostomy on functional outcome at 6 months among patients with severe stroke receiving mechanical ventilation: the SETPOINT2 randomized clinical trial, JAMA (2022)
- National Tracheostomy Safety Project, Patient and family resources
Tags: tracheostomytracheostomy caretracheostomy tubetracheotomyventilatorolder adultsBreathing supportCompressor nebuliserHealth monitoring devicesHealthy ageing
This article is for general education and is not medical advice. Ask a doctor or pharmacist about your own situation before changing any exercise, diet or medicine.
