What mustard oil is
Mustard oil comes from the seeds of plants of the mustard family, most commonly Brassica juncea in India. In Hindi it is sarson ka tel. The seeds are crushed in a press, and the oil may be sold in two broad ways. Traditional, pungent, strongly flavoured oil, often marketed as kachchi ghani, is pressed without refining. Refined mustard oil is processed to reduce the smell and bitterness. The sharp taste of the unrefined oil comes from naturally occurring compounds in the seed, notably allyl isothiocyanate, which is also what makes mustard and wasabi pungent.
In the kitchen it is used for frying, tempering, pickling and marinades. Outside the kitchen it has a long history as a massage oil and as a hair and skin oil. The older version of this page suggested that a "Grade-2" oil is meant only for massage. None of the sources cited here recognises such a category, and families should be careful about any oil whose label does not say it is meant for eating.
Why regulators disagree about it
The central scientific debate concerns erucic acid. The 2022 review in the Journal of Clinical Lipidology, written by a group of lipid specialists, summarises it plainly: mustard oil is low in saturated fat, which is a point in its favour, but it contains a high proportion of erucic acid, which in rodents accumulated in heart muscle and caused damage called myocardial lipidosis. Because of that, some regulators restrict it. The US FDA does not allow it for cooking, and Australia, New Zealand and the EU set upper limits on how much erucic acid can be consumed. The review adds that 29 countries allow limited amounts for human consumption. The Lipid Association of India, according to the same review, has recommended mustard oil as heart-healthy. The authors conclude that the regulatory and specialist positions differ, that some benefits have been reported in humans, and that the FDA should review its safety limits. They also point to canola, olive, sunflower and soybean oils as alternatives that can suit South Asian cooking.
The 2025 Nutrition Reviews paper reaches a similar position from another direction. It describes the harms seen in animals, such as fat accumulation in heart and liver, notes that high-erucic mustard oil is still widely consumed in Asia, and says that limited human studies suggest possible protective effects in acute myocardial infarction, ischaemic heart disease and neurological disorders. The authors set out to clarify whether erucic acid acts more as a toxicant or as a therapeutic agent. The honest summary is that the question is not settled. Rodent findings do not automatically apply to people eating normal amounts, and the human studies are limited.
What this means in practice is that two reasonable positions exist, and a family should not be told that mustard oil is either poison or medicine. For an older person with heart disease, high cholesterol, fatty liver or diabetes, the question belongs with the doctor or dietitian who knows them.
What the heart evidence shows
Most of the research on dietary fat asks what replaces what. The American Heart Association's 2017 presidential advisory reports that in randomised trials, replacing saturated fat with polyunsaturated vegetable oil lowered cardiovascular disease by roughly 30 percent, while replacing it with refined carbohydrate or sugar did not. A Cochrane review by Hooper and colleagues (2020) of 15 trials with 56,675 participants found a 17 percent lower risk of combined cardiovascular events when saturated fat was reduced for at least two years, with little or no effect on deaths. It concluded that replacing saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat or carbohydrate appears useful, and that the effect of replacing it with monounsaturated fat remains unclear.
These are general findings about fats, not about mustard oil. They explain why a cooking oil that is low in saturated fat can be a reasonable swap for ghee, butter or coconut oil, which are high in it. That is the main argument made for mustard oil, and it is the argument the Lipid Association of India position rests on. It does not follow that more mustard oil is better. The World Health Organization's healthy diet fact sheet suggests limiting total fat to 30 percent or less of daily energy, saturated fat to under 10 percent and trans fat to under 1 percent, and describes fish, avocado, nuts and sunflower, soybean, canola and olive oils as preferred unsaturated sources. Mustard oil is not named on that list. The AHA's 2021 dietary guidance advises using liquid plant oils in place of tropical oils and partially hydrogenated fats, which also covers many oils, not one in particular.
Mustard oil contains alpha-linolenic acid (ALA), a plant omega-3 fat, and that is the basis of the claim that it is rich in omega-3. The Cochrane review on omega-3 fats (Abdelhamid and colleagues, 2020) found that increasing ALA probably makes little or no difference to all-cause mortality (risk ratio 1.01) and may slightly reduce cardiovascular events (risk ratio 0.95, low certainty, confidence interval 0.83 to 1.07, which includes no effect), and probably slightly reduces arrhythmia (risk ratio 0.73). In other words, the benefit is small and uncertain. It is not a reason to expect mustard oil to protect the heart on its own, and omega-3 capsules are covered in other guides.
For the practical question of how much oil of any type an older Indian eats a day, how many times it is reused, and how it compares with groundnut, rice bran, olive and coconut oils, see Best Cooking Oils for Seniors, Olive Oil Benefits for Seniors and Coconut Oil for Older Adults. Cholesterol numbers are covered in Cholesterol in Older Adults.
Claims that go further than the evidence
The earlier version of this page listed mustard oil as a help for cancer, asthma, brain health and joint pain. These claims were drawn from laboratory findings, such as the effect of a compound in mustard on cancer cells in a dish, or from the presence of a nutrient in the oil. Findings of this kind are a starting point for research, not evidence that eating or applying the oil treats a disease in a person.
- Cancer. None of the sources cited in this guide describes mustard oil as a treatment for cancer. Anyone with cancer, or a family member caring for one, should follow the oncology team's plan and ask them about any food or oil taken in unusual amounts.
- Asthma. The claim that selenium in the oil relieves asthma is not backed by the sources reviewed here. Asthma needs its own assessment and medicines prescribed by a doctor.
- Brain health. The Nutrition Reviews paper mentions only limited human findings on neurological disorders. That is not evidence of protection against memory loss.
- Joints and arthritis. The NHS page on osteoarthritis treatment calls exercise one of the most important treatments, says being overweight often worsens osteoarthritis because of the extra strain on joints, and lists painkillers, topical anti-inflammatory creams and hot or cold packs as options. It describes massage as a physiotherapist's hands-on manual therapy. It does not list mustard oil. A warm massage can feel comforting and ease stiffness for a while, and that is a legitimate reason families do it. Persistent knee or hip pain is something for a doctor to assess. See knee osteoarthritis at home.
On the skin: massage and irritation
The pungent compounds that give mustard oil its smell can irritate. The NHS explains that contact dermatitis occurs when a substance damages the outer layer of the skin or triggers an allergic reaction, causing skin that is itchy, blistered, dry or cracked, usually within hours or days of exposure. Older skin tends to be thinner and drier, and an older person with delicate skin, eczema or a skin infection may be more likely to react. The NHS advises seeing a GP if symptoms are persistent, recurrent or severe, and notes that avoiding the trigger is the key step. Mustard oil is also flammable when heated, and warming it near a flame or in the microwave before a massage can cause burns. A caregiver should keep it away from broken skin and the face, eyes and genital area.
Adulteration and epidemic dropsy
Cooking oil is one of the foods most often adulterated. The most serious danger in India is mustard oil mixed, deliberately or accidentally, with the oil of the argemone plant, whose seeds look like mustard seeds. A review by Das and Khanna in Critical Reviews in Toxicology describes epidemic dropsy as the illness that results when argemone seed contaminates mustard seed oil, with outbreaks reported in India, Mauritius, Fiji and South Africa. Symptoms include nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea, swelling of the limbs, skin redness, breathlessness and, in severe cases, glaucoma and death from cardiac arrest. The toxicity is attributed to two alkaloids, sanguinarine and dihydrosanguinarine. Treatment has been mainly supportive, and there is no specific cure, which is why prevention matters.
This is a food-safety question, so the safest approach for a family is the usual one: choose sealed, labelled, packed oil from a reputable shop with a food-safety licence number rather than loose oil of unknown origin, and report suspect oil to the local food-safety officer. If several household members develop swelling of the feet or legs, breathlessness or unexplained illness after a change of oil, a doctor should be told promptly about the oil.
Heat, reuse and amount
How much oil is appropriate for an older person depends on their weight, activity, heart health and diet, and a dietitian or doctor sets it. Repeated heating of any frying oil is addressed in Best Cooking Oils for Seniors, which cites the Indian food-safety authority's guidance. Hot oil is also a burn and fire hazard for older cooks, which is covered in kitchen safety for older adults.
When to see a doctor
This guide is general information, not medical advice. It does not replace a doctor, nurse or pharmacist who knows your situation.
Emergency (call 112 in India):
- The NHS lists tight or squeezing chest pain that may spread to the arms, neck or jaw, severe breathlessness, sweating, nausea and pale, blue or grey skin as heart attack symptoms and advises calling the emergency number straight away rather than driving to hospital. Eating any particular oil does not protect against these.
- Sudden swelling of the lips, mouth, tongue or throat, or severe difficulty breathing, which the NHS lists among the signs of a severe allergic reaction that need an emergency call.
See a doctor soon about:
- A rash, blistering or soreness after using mustard oil on the skin.
- Swelling of both legs or feet, breathlessness or sudden illness in more than one person after using the same oil. Mention the oil.
- High cholesterol, heart disease, diabetes or fatty liver and questions about which oil to use.
- Joint pain, swelling or stiffness that is persistent or limits walking.
- Unplanned weight loss or loss of appetite.
Equipment mentioned in this guide
Frequently asked questions
Is mustard oil good for the heart?
Evidence is mixed. A 2022 review notes it is low in saturated fat but high in erucic acid, and that regulators and specialists disagree. A doctor or dietitian can advise on a particular person.
Why is mustard oil restricted in some countries?
According to a 2022 review in the Journal of Clinical Lipidology, the US FDA does not allow it for cooking because of erucic acid, while Australia, New Zealand and the EU set intake limits and 29 countries allow limited amounts.
Does mustard oil cure cancer or asthma?
No source cited here says so. Laboratory findings are not proof of treatment in people, so these conditions need care from a doctor.
Can mustard oil massage help arthritis?
The NHS lists exercise, weight management, medicines and hot or cold packs as osteoarthritis treatments and does not list mustard oil. Massage may feel soothing, but persistent joint pain needs medical assessment.
What is epidemic dropsy?
A poisoning that occurs when argemone seed oil contaminates mustard oil, with outbreaks reported in India. Symptoms include limb swelling, breathlessness, vomiting and diarrhoea.
Is kachchi ghani oil safer than refined oil?
The sources cited here do not compare them. Both come from mustard seed, and the main safety points are erucic acid and whether the oil is pure and labelled.
Sources and further reading
- Poddar KH et al., Mustard oil and cardiovascular health: Why the controversy? Journal of Clinical Lipidology (2022)
- Mohanty S et al., Paradoxical Effects of Erucic Acid: A Fatty Acid With Two-Faced Implications, Nutrition Reviews (2025)
- Das M, Khanna SK, Clinicoepidemiological, toxicological, and safety evaluation studies on argemone oil, Critical Reviews in Toxicology (1997)
- Abdelhamid AS et al., Omega-3 fatty acids for the primary and secondary prevention of cardiovascular disease, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2020)
- Hooper L et al., Reduction in saturated fat intake for cardiovascular disease, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2020)
- Sacks FM et al., Dietary Fats and Cardiovascular Disease: A Presidential Advisory From the American Heart Association, Circulation (2017)
- World Health Organization, Healthy diet fact sheet
- NHS, Osteoarthritis treatment
Tags: mustard oilsarson ka telerucic acidheart healthcooking oilepidemic dropsyolder adultsGut health and nutritionHealthy ageingElder care
This article is for general education and is not medical advice. Ask a doctor or pharmacist about your own situation before changing any exercise, diet or medicine.
